No, Tom Brady, the NFL isn’t any weaker than the AFC East

Finally, someone has challenged the great Tom Brady. Despite his six championship rings and numerous records, Brady is not immune to criticism. Recently, he made comments about the current state of the NFL, expressing his belief that the product is not as good as when he was a younger player. Alex Smith, a former NFL quarterback with 16 seasons under his belt, responded to Brady’s remarks, highlighting some valid points.

Smith questioned Brady’s complaint, pointing out that he had just won a Super Bowl in the current game. It seems strange for Brady to discount the success he had in the league only a short while ago. Additionally, Smith criticized Brady for playing in what he believes is the most uncompetitive division in NFL history. The AFC East, which includes the New England Patriots, has been known for its lack of strong competition throughout much of Brady’s career.

Smith’s comments shed light on some important aspects of Brady’s career. While Brady has undoubtedly been one of the greatest quarterbacks of all time, he has also been fortunate in certain circumstances. For example, the NFL implemented rule changes regarding contact made by defensive backs after five yards. This was a direct response to the physical style of play exhibited by the Patriots’ secondary during their early Super Bowl wins. Brady benefited from these rule changes, as it made it easier for him to connect with his receivers down the field.

Furthermore, Smith mentioned Brady’s injury in the 2008 season, where he suffered a torn ACL due to a hit below the knee. This incident led to changes in the rules regarding hits on quarterbacks, particularly low hits. Brady’s injury played a significant role in prompting the league to take head injuries more seriously.

Smith’s critique of the AFC East is also worth considering. While Brady has faced tough opponents throughout his career, the lack of strong competition within his division has undoubtedly contributed to the Patriots’ success. The Buffalo Bills, Miami Dolphins, and New York Jets have all struggled to consistently perform at a high level, allowing the Patriots to accumulate wins and secure division titles more easily.

In conclusion, Alex Smith’s response to Tom Brady’s comments brings an important perspective to the table. While Brady has achieved incredible success throughout his career, it is essential to acknowledge the factors that have contributed to his achievements. Smith’s reminder of the mediocre competition within the AFC East and the rule changes that benefited Brady’s style of play brings a sense of balance to the conversation. It is crucial to recognize both the greatness of Brady’s career and the circumstances that have influenced his success.